Nrl Form Team?

[benji6]

What do u think the form team would be so far?like in each position which player

[Alec]

Sydney Roosters maybe.

[NRL2007]

1. Billy Slater
2. Israel Folau
3. Michael Gordon
4. Ashley Graham
5. Nathan Merritt
6. Kurt Gidley
7. Johnathon Thurston
8. Jason King
9. Cameron Smith
10. Carl Webb
11. David Kidwell
12. Andrew Ryan
13. Glenn Stewart

14. Matt Bowen
15. Lance Thompson
16. Peter Cusack
17. Steve Price

[go you roosters]

1. Billy Slater
2. Israel Folau
3. Michael Gordon
4. Ashley Graham
5. Nathan Merritt
6. Kurt Gidley
7. Johnathon Thurston
8. Jason King
9. Cameron Smith
10. Carl Webb
11. David Kidwell
12. Andrew Ryan
13. Glenn Stewart

14. Matt Bowen
15. Lance Thompson
16. Peter Cusack
17. Steve Price

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

[Mr.Sark]

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
He has actually been playing very very well, but there are many players above him so far this season tbh.

[go you roosters]

He has actually been playing very very well, but there are many players above him so far this season tbh.
Therefore making it LOL worthy

[NRL2007]

Therefore making it LOL worthy
Who would you put there? :o

[Wogboy]

1. Billy Slater
2. Israel Folau
3. Michael Gordon
4. Ashley Graham
5. Nathan Merritt
6. Kurt Gidley
7. Johnathon Thurston
8. Jason King
9. Cameron Smith
10. Carl Webb
11. David Kidwell
12. Andrew Ryan
13. Glenn Stewart

14. Matt Bowen
15. Lance Thompson
16. Peter Cusack
17. Steve Price
Pretty accurate team IMO.

[go you roosters]

Who would you put there? :o
Probably hodges as atm he is in form

[NRL2007]

One good game warrants form?

[go you roosters]

One good game warrants form?
There has been 3 rounds ffs! He looks alot more dangerous than ashley graham rofl

[wireando]

Kurt Gidley has been playing well, but how can he be the number one stand off when he hasn't even been playing there?

[go you roosters]

Kurt Gidley has been playing well, but how can he be the number one stand off when he hasn't even been playing there?
Where have u been the first 2 rounds?? He played 5/8th for 77 minutes of round 1 and 80 minutes of round 2

[Toast]

Laffranchi deserves to be in there Imo.

Rogers had one good game :p

[Marit Lage]

Where have u been the first 2 rounds?? He played 5/8th for 77 minutes of round 1 and 80 minutes of round 2
He played there in attack in Round 2 - but he was still playing fullback in defence for a lot of it. He also spent various periods of rounds 1 and 2 at hooker.

[Marit Lage]

There has been 3 rounds ffs! He looks alot more dangerous than ashley graham rofl
No he doesn't actually. Ashley Graham has gunned it every week this season.

[Marit Lage]

Falou, conversely, is lol-worthy. He's scored a try or two, but in general he's been quite poor IMO. Caught out of position often, looks poor in defence given his size, and just doesn't look quite ready for first grade in general IMO.

[speirz]

I can't believe Folau is being talked up as the new Meninga and being an Origin bolter, especially with the players Qld already has in the backline.

[10rossli]

1:Billy Slater
2:Nathan Merritt
3:Justin Hodges
4:Nigel Vagana
5:Micheal Crockett
6:Travis Burns
7:Jonathon Thurston
8:Peter Cusak
9:Cameron Smith
10:Steve Price
11:Anthony Watmough
12:Lance Thompson
13:David Kidwell
------------------------------------------
14:David Fa'alogo
15:Shane Tronc
16:Andrew Ryan
17:Matt Bowen/Davia Peachey

[Mr J]

1. B Slater
2. W McKinnon
3. D Peachey
4. J Hodges
5. M Bowen
6. K Gidgley
7. J Thurston
8. J Ryles
9. R Farah
10. M O'Meley
11. F Pritchard
12. A Laffranchi
13. A Ryan

14. T Carney
15. M Ballin/ G Bird
16. P Cusack
17. S Price

[Toast]

1. B Slater
2. W McKinnon
3. D Peachey
4. J Hodges
5. M Bowen
6. K Gidgley
7. J Thurston
8. J Ryles
9. R Farah
10. M O'Meley
11. F Pritchard
12. A Laffranchi
13. A Ryan

14. T Carney
15. M Ballin/ G Bird
16. P Cusack
17. S Price
PRetty much on the money. Apart from O'Meley Imo.

[Marit Lage]

PRetty much on the money. Apart from O'Meley Imo.
And apart from the fact that he stacked his backline with fullbacks...

Bowen would be a horrible winger. I'd rather have David Howell and that's saying something.

[Mr J]

Actually, you should be disagreeing with this team twofold mate.

It's made up purely off the Dally M votes up to the 3rd round of competition.....



lol @ the whole backline being fullbacks though....

[Mr J]

1. B Slater
2. I Falou
3. J Lyon
4. J Hodges
5. M Crockett
6. K Gidgley
7. J Thurston
8. J Ryles
9. R Farah
10. M O'Meley
11. F Pritchard
12. A Laffranchi
13. A Ryan

14. T Carney
15. M Ballin/ G Bird
16. P Cusack
17. S Price

[Marit Lage]

*nitpicks*

Get Falou out of there!

And spell Gidley correctly!

[Toast]

*nitpicks*

Get Falou out of there!

And spell Gidley correctly!
We are spelling it according to the great Benji.

Kurt and Mat Gigdley

[Marit Lage]

We are spelling it according to the great Benji.

Kurt and Mat Gigdley
http://www.haxed.co.uk/cms/uploads/pics/giant_rolleyes.gif

[Toast]

http://www.haxed.co.uk/cms/uploads/pics/giant_rolleyes.gif
You look B-E-A-utiful today

[Mr J]

Falou has the most Dally M points out of the wingers though.....

And you shut up about Gigdgley, he'll come good.

[Marit Lage]

Falou has the most Dally M points out of the wingers though.....

And you shut up about Gigdgley, he'll come good.
Dally M points mean squat all when selecting things like this. As I've said many times before, they are only useful in deciding who the best player of the season was/is, and even then I could see problems. Once I get this week's RLW, I'll post up the real side!

[Mr J]

Dally M points mean squat all when selecting things like this. As I've said many times before, they are only useful in deciding who the best player of the season was/is, and even then I could see problems. Once I get this week's RLW, I'll post up the real side!
That will probably be the best way to gauge, the only problem is with consistency, players who have had a match off are no chance at being the best to date. I disagree that someone with 3 games at 7/10 has been a better player than one with 2 x 10/10.

Dally M is a pointless way to do it though, a winger could have been the 4th best player on the field over the 3 games and been dynamic, but will still be beaten by a bloke who's dropped 6,000,000 balls in his 2 games, but snuck a few tries in the other.


Took a while, I got a bite though. :)

[Marit Lage]

That will probably be the best way to gauge, the only problem is with consistency, players who have had a match off are no chance at being the best to date. I disagree that someone with 3 games at 7/10 has been a better player than one with 2 x 10/10.

Dally M is a pointless way to do it though, a winger could have been the 4th best player on the field over the 3 games and been dynamic, but will still be beaten by a bloke who's dropped 6,000,000 balls in his 2 games, but snuck a few tries in the other.


Took a while, I got a bite though. :)
That's where averages come into it. 10-10 is better than 7-7-7 because a player averages 10, compared to the 7 the other player averages. 7-7-7 is better than 10-10-0 though, because someone who has the worst game of all time every three matches is obviously a big liability to their side even if they can produce some gun performances.

[Mr J]

But that is flawed also, given that if a bloke plays one game all year, and it just turns out to be a blinder, that makes him the best player.

Hmm, actually, that is correct anyway isn't it...... hmm.... (http://www.bulldogs.com.au/main.php?page=player&id=659&grade=nrl)

[Marit Lage]

But that is flawed also, given that if a bloke plays one game all year, and it just turns out to be a blinder, that makes him the best player.

Hmm, actually, that is correct anyway isn't it...... hmm.... (http://www.bulldogs.com.au/main.php?page=player&id=659&grade=nrl)
At the end of the season, I'll go by averages with a minimum requirement of matches, obviously. Like when you see the list of the best cricket averages... they all have a minimum requirement.

At this stage, there's too little games already played to worry about that minimums. And as you said, 10-10 is better than 7-7-7.

And as for Williams, you'll be happy to know he averages a whole 0 from one game played this year.

[Mr J]

But Johns would have unfairly picked up a 0 from that match also

[Marit Lage]

But Johns would have unfairly picked up a 0 from that match also
Johns got 3.

[Mr J]

Irrelevant.

Still going to knock his average around.