Best Prop Forward

SteRhino1988 · 07-09-2005, 01:38 AM

I think it's Stuart Fielden. He's the most determined runner ever and he regularly plays 80 mins. id love to see him smashing Mark O'Meley and Willie Mason in the NRL.

Joey's Mum 182 · 07-09-2005, 01:40 AM

fielden is a wuss compared to mason and o'mealy... didnt you watch tri-nations?

SteRhino1988 · 07-09-2005, 01:42 AM

I was there it was hard for him our half backs werent on top making it hard for the forwards to make ground. tell me do them two play 80 mins?

Doggiesfan · 07-09-2005, 01:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteRhino1988

I was there it was hard for him our half backs werent on top making it hard for the forwards to make ground. tell me do them two play 80 mins?

Steve Price does.

bulldogs · 07-09-2005, 01:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey's Mum 182

fielden is a wuss compared to mason and o'mealy... didnt you watch tri-nations?

lol... Stuart Fielden is like half the size of Mason. But he's quite a good player though.

I think apart from Webcke (who has retired from rep)... Steve Price is the best prop in the world at the moment. A consistent player who plays the full 80mins, tops the hits up week in week out.

Doggiesfan · 07-09-2005, 01:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteRhino1988

I think it's Stuart Fielden. He's the most determined runner ever and he regularly plays 80 mins. id love to see him smashing Mark O'Meley and Willie Mason in the NRL.

Never gonna happen.

Asotasi is the best prop. He's made more metres than any other prop in the NRL and the second most amount of hitups for a prop in the NRL and can play 80 minutes (in the toughest comp). Playing 80 minutes in ESL is similar to playing 60 minutes in NRL.

Asotasi also hits like a ton of feathers (which, if you go back to year 3, weighs the same as a ton of bricks).

bulldogs · 07-09-2005, 01:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Doggiesfan

Never gonna happen.

Asotasi is the best prop. He's made more metres than any other prop in the NRL and the second most amount of hitups for a prop in the NRL and can play 80 minutes (in the toughest comp). Playing 80 minutes in ESL is similar to playing 60 minutes in NRL.

Asotasi also hits like a ton of feathers (which, if you go back to year 3, weighs the same as a ton of bricks).

Asotasi has been in superb form... but not the best prop. I would rate him as one of the most improved player of the year though.

Doggiesfan · 07-09-2005, 01:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bulldogs

Asotasi has been in superb form... but not the best prop. I would rate him as one of the most improved player of the year though.

Why not the best? ?He has more metres than any other prop.

bulldogs · 07-09-2005, 01:54 AM

That's rating him purely in terms of metres gained. There's a lot of other things, many of which are little things that props need to do which aren't recorded as statistics.

SteRhino1988 · 07-09-2005, 02:10 AM

Fielden could play 80 mins in the NRL no problem. Doesnt take a backward step and has more desire than any other forward on the planet. I think the aussies cant accept a british player better than their own because they are bitter about the cricket. haha!

Broncos_my_team · 07-09-2005, 02:17 AM

I believe Shane Webke is the undisputed best prop forward in the game. Call me byast but his heart is in the game. How many can say they've came back from a medial ligament tear after one week's rest to back up for their club?

Steve Price is also another worthy to compare. QLD sorely missed him in the last two origin games...

EDIT: and for the record; england has been bitter about the cricket for the last decade and a half. Give it a rest mate.

RoostersFAN · 07-09-2005, 02:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteRhino1988

Fielden could play 80 mins in the NRL no problem. Doesnt take a backward step and has more desire than any other forward on the planet. I think the aussies cant accept a british player better than their own because they are bitter about the cricket. haha!

hey guys im new to this board.. my first post and i gotta have a say.. i love my league.... but dont forget Fielden and the English Super League is no where near the level of the Australian competition... i dont think Fielden would make a full 80mins in this comp... especially how quality this season has been....

in terms of best props, hands down to Shane Webcke, some1 mentioned him be4, he's been consistantly good week in week out for years and years and years, always plays at full speed no matter what the situation

Y2Chillenium · 07-09-2005, 06:11 AM

LUKE "BULL" BAILEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Runs like his life depended on it every hit up.

Cover tackles like a lock.

Can chase down backs and kicks.

The fittest, fatest, most reliable prop in the world.

Half Kast · 07-09-2005, 10:45 AM

The Dally M Prop of the Year will/should be between Luke Bailey, Shane Webke and Roy Asotasi. Steve Price could of been up there but injury made him miss alot of games.

Roys the man, I think this year hes stepped up heaps. He was pretty much the Bulldogs forward pack for a while when everyone was injured. He would play like, 60-70 mins straight most games and play all 80 in others. His stats are awesome and in the real games he can make some very good game breakers, wheather it be a big hit, try saver or a big run. In my opinion hes the best prop...

...but he wont win the Dally M. That will be Bailey or Webke.

pantherszrdylz · 07-09-2005, 11:20 AM

luke bailey,steven price

RoostersFAN · 07-09-2005, 02:16 PM

Why would u ppl think luke bailey?.. sure hes had an awesome year but where has been year in year out?...i cant remember the last time he had a year like this....... hes going well cause the dragons are going well.... lets see how he backs it up next season i guess

league-05 · 07-09-2005, 03:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RoostersFAN

Why would u ppl think luke bailey?.. sure hes had an awesome year but where has been year in year out?...i cant remember the last time he had a year like this....... hes going well cause the dragons are going well.... lets see how he backs it up next season i guess

The medals are awarded for this years performances by players.

richie76 · 07-09-2005, 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteRhino1988

Fielden could play 80 mins in the NRL no problem. Doesnt take a backward step and has more desire than any other forward on the planet. I think the aussies cant accept a british player better than their own because they are bitter about the cricket. haha!

Well bring him on...we'd love to see how Stuart Fielden can perform here...I accepted the fact that Ellery Hanley was an amazing player in the Winfield Cup back in the day so I can accept a good UK player coming here and succeeding..I am a Morley fan even....and about being bitter...Poms have been since 1989 regarding cricket and well...lets not talk about League haha....just think about this...how many UK players are playing in the NRL compared to Aussies/Kiwis playing in Superleague?....now why is that again? haha...but hey will an NRL Club even give Fielden a contract?..thats another thing too..oh BTW..I'd rather have Asotasi anyday.

RoostersFAN · 07-09-2005, 05:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by league-05

The medals are awarded for this years performances by players.

i know that.. but i thought this thread was talking about the best prop forward of the recent decade or something.. not of this year.....

Storm · 07-09-2005, 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteRhino1988

I was there it was hard for him our half backs werent on top making it hard for the forwards to make ground. tell me do them two play 80 mins?

It's the forwards job to get ontop to allow the halves to do their stuff. Not the other way around.

Best Prop in the world in Steve Price, followed by Bailey. We will see at the end of the year, anyway.

SteRhino1988 · 08-09-2005, 01:07 AM

Yes but the half backs werent getting involved meaning our forwards had to take it straight from the ruck and get banged they should have been put through gaps by the half backs

alex_the_rooster_man · 08-09-2005, 01:30 AM

I think Jason Cayless and Adrian Morley are the best front row pairings

RoostersFAN · 08-09-2005, 03:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by alex_the_rooster_man

I think Jason Cayless and Adrian Morley are the best front row pairings

no way man... im a rooster man my self but i disagree with ya... moz is an awesome player 1 of my favourites.. but they arnt the best front row pairings.......
Webcke and Civoneciva and
Ryles and Bailey

are 2 very good front row pairings.. and of late
O'meley and Asotasi

pimpsnz · 08-09-2005, 09:33 AM

Hard to go past Luke Bailey

6Roosterman · 08-09-2005, 11:09 AM

Adrian Morley is the best

da dogs rule 4 life · 08-09-2005, 11:13 AM

luke bailey is probably the best right NOW!

Y2Chillenium · 09-09-2005, 05:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RoostersFAN

Why would u ppl think luke bailey?.. sure hes had an awesome year but where has been year in year out?...i cant remember the last time he had a year like this....... hes going well cause the dragons are going well.... lets see how he backs it up next season i guess

Luke Bailey has been an awesome player since he debuted...

And if you're talking about high profile games he whooped ass in the last 2 Origin series and also came back after missing most of last season to play against the Panthers in the finals and was Dragons best player on the night.

leaguefan · 09-09-2005, 04:14 PM

to the clown who started this thread

you are kidding stuart fielden is an imposter just cause he plays 80 minutes doesn't mean he is the best prop its probably cause he spends most of it on the wing

smash O'Merely and Mason you are a joke

league-05 · 09-09-2005, 04:21 PM

Stuart Fielden is probably like Danny Nutley, and he's not Australia's best.

SteRhino1988 · 10-09-2005, 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by leaguefan

to the clown who started this thread

you are kidding stuart fielden is an imposter just cause he plays 80 minutes doesn't mean he is the best prop its probably cause he spends most of it on the wing

smash O'Merely and Mason you are a joke

Listen i dont doubt that mason and o'meley are great prop forwards but in my opinion Fielden is the best in the world and he does anything but hang out on the wing as his team are reliant on him driving it in every set as well as his defensive skills.You obviously haven't seen him in action much. I have noticed that alot of aussies on here are very narrow minded towards super league and yes we have established many times that nrl is better but disrespecting a competition that you aint even seen is just plain stupid! and you call me a joke

bulldogs · 10-09-2005, 12:15 PM

Any prop forward that plays the 80mins in any competition isn't a poor player. But he is definitely not the best in the world, that title easily belongs to Webcke, Price might have a case to argue.... morley, mason, o'meley, fielden, petro.... they are all a level below webcke and price.

leaguefan · 10-09-2005, 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteRhino1988

Listen i dont doubt that mason and o'meley are great prop forwards but in my opinion Fielden is the best in the world and he does anything but hang out on the wing as his team are reliant on him driving it in every set as well as his defensive skills.You obviously haven't seen him in action much. I have noticed that alot of aussies on here are very narrow minded towards super league and yes we have established many times that nrl is better but disrespecting a competition that you aint even seen is just plain stupid! and you call me a joke

i watch super league its on fox sports televised games every weekend

and your still a clown and a joke

Stuart Fielden is an imposter when compared to our best props he doesn't even measure up the super league comp is full of second rate aussies that couldn't get a start in the NRL and they seem to carve up the super league when they are way past there best so it doesn't say much for your comp

warriors2005 · 10-09-2005, 04:22 PM

i agree. super league is full of old nrl players. u dont see old super league players heading to the nrl. price was awsome at the bulldogs but at the warriors i havent been that impressed with him.

1.webcke
2. bailey
3. o meley
4. price
5. petro

ifeta palea'sina is the best running prop but thats it

alex_the_rooster_man · 10-09-2005, 06:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RoostersFAN

no way man... im a rooster man my self but i disagree with ya... moz is an awesome player 1 of my favourites.. but they arnt the best front row pairings.......
Webcke and Civoneciva and
Ryles and Bailey

are 2 very good front row pairings.. and of late
O'meley and Asotasi

They are about equal with webcke and cimoneciva. Cayless i think is better than morley and i think that they are better then Ryles and Bailey

No Way!!! Ur a Rooster fan u always say other players are better and then gonna lose and like that uve even swapped teams of who u go for like from parramatta to roosters u only go for the successfu teams like parra 2001 then roosters 2002-2005 next year it will be the dragons or eels again

RoostersFAN · 10-09-2005, 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by alex_the_rooster_man

They are about equal with webcke and cimoneciva. Cayless i think is better than morley and i think that they are better then Ryles and Bailey

No Way!!! Ur a Rooster fan u always say other players are better and then gonna lose and like that uve even swapped teams of who u go for like from parramatta to roosters u only go for the successfu teams like parra 2001 then roosters 2002-2005 next year it will be the dragons or eels again

LOL wtf are u smoking?.. i've been a roosters fan for 10years u moron.. show me where i said i go for parra or the successful teams?... i just disagreed with some1 sayn that cayless and moz were the best forward pairing in the comp.... unlike u i can identify other good players on teams and i dont just sit there and say every roosters player is better then every1 else blah blahh blahhh....

bulldogs · 10-09-2005, 08:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by alex_the_rooster_man

They are about equal with webcke and cimoneciva. Cayless i think is better than morley and i think that they are better then Ryles and Bailey

No Way!!! Ur a Rooster fan u always say other players are better and then gonna lose and like that uve even swapped teams of who u go for like from parramatta to roosters u only go for the successfu teams like parra 2001 then roosters 2002-2005 next year it will be the dragons or eels again

At least his is being realistic...

RoostersFAN · 10-09-2005, 08:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bulldogs

At least his is being realistic...

being realistic by saying im a band wagon roosters fan?...

alex_the_rooster_man · 10-09-2005, 08:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bulldogs

At least his is being realistic...

How is he there both INTERNATIONAL FORWARDS

alex_the_rooster_man · 10-09-2005, 08:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RoostersFAN

LOL wtf are u smoking?.. i've been a roosters fan for 10years u moron.. show me where i said i go for parra or the successful teams?... i just disagreed with some1 sayn that cayless and moz were the best forward pairing in the comp.... unlike u i can identify other good players on teams and i dont just sit there and say every roosters player is better then every1 else blah blahh blahhh....

Sorry i thought u were rooster boy

Bulldogs_4_life · 10-09-2005, 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RoostersFAN

being realistic by saying im a band wagon roosters fan?...

He meant that you were being Realistic..